How do you get every stakeholder into the first review round?
To get every stakeholder into round 1, find out before the first cut who can change the outcome, put all of them on the round 1 invite with a fixed closing date, and give people who only need to watch a different link and a different job from the person who decides. The work happens at kickoff, not at the review: once a regional lead or an executive sponsor first sees the film in round three, you are already paying for it.
Why do late stakeholders cost so much?
Because their notes reopen decisions that everyone else already made.
A late stakeholder is not being difficult when they question the structure in round three. They simply did not see round one, where the structure was agreed. Their note is reasonable from where they stand, and it undoes work for everyone else. PlayPause, a review-tool vendor, writes that teams see three to four times more revision rounds when external stakeholders enter after round 1. The vendor does not show the study behind the figure, so treat it as an indication. The mechanism is familiar to anyone who has produced a commercial: each new voice brings a new set of first impressions, and first impressions belong to round 1.
Ziflow’s guide to approval workflows makes a related point from the other side: late comments should not reopen a stage that was already cleared, but belong to the next version. That only works if the people who could have commented were invited in time.
Who counts as a stakeholder on an agency job?
Anyone whose “no” can change the film, whether or not they appear in the brief.
An agency producer sits between the brand and the production company. The IPA describes the role as managing the production from idea to execution while representing the client and managing expectations. That middle position is exactly why the producer has to map the people on both sides. A typical map for a brand commercial looks like this.
| Stakeholder | What they usually care about | Needs round 1? | Decides? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand marketing lead | Message, product, campaign fit | Yes | Often the named decision maker |
| Regional or market lead | Local relevance, cast, language | Yes, if they can block the film | Inside their market only |
| Legal or regulatory reviewer | Claims, supers, required lines | Yes, for claims in the script and cut | Only on their remit |
| Senior sponsor (CMO, founder) | Overall impression | Yes, or through a live session | Sometimes, which is why you ask |
| Agency creative director | Idea, craft, tone | Yes, internally before the client | Internally |
| Agency account lead | Client relationship, timing | Yes, internally | No |
| Director and editor | Execution | They receive the notes | No |
| Social or media team | Formats, cutdowns, first seconds | Watch only, unless formats are on the table | No |
The map is not a formality. The row you leave out is the one that turns up in round three.
How do you find the hidden approver before round 1?
Ask three direct questions at kickoff and write the answers down.
- “Who else will see this before it goes live?” Not who should approve it, but who will see it. People who see it will comment.
- “Who changed the last campaign late?” Most marketing leads know exactly who did, and are relieved to be asked.
- “Who approves the cost if something changes?” The person who signs off budget for changes often has opinions on the creative too.
Then send the client a short note that lists the reviewers for round 1, the named decision maker, the date the round opens and the date it closes. Asking the client to confirm that list in writing is the single most useful sentence in the whole project. It moves the question “who else?” from round three to week one, when the answer is still free.
Should everyone get the same review link?
No. Watching and deciding are different jobs, and the link should say which one a person has.
Ziflow draws the same line between reviewers, who give input without blocking progress, and approvers, who make a binding decision for a stage. When everyone gets the same link and the same approve button, the first person to press it decides for the group, and the rest feel bypassed. A cleaner setup:
- A general view link for people who need to stay informed: the social team, the wider agency team, a curious executive. They watch, and their comments go to the brand lead rather than straight to the edit.
- Personal links for the people who are on the round 1 list. Each comment carries a name, so the producer knows who said what.
- One decision maker, who sends or confirms the consolidated list and gives the verdict.
Review platforms handle this in different ways. In Kadrenta, made by the same team behind The Production Brief, a client link needs no account: people give their name on arrival, the link can carry a passphrase, and it has a closing moment for responses. Agency teams can keep internal comments separate from client comments, so the creative director’s notes never land in front of the brand by accident.
How do you make round 1 worth everyone’s time?
Tell reviewers what to judge, and give them a fixed time to do it.
A busy marketing director who opens a rough cut without context will comment on whatever stands out, often the temp music or the ungraded color. That wastes the round and their goodwill. Before round 1, send each reviewer a short note:
- What this version is: a rough cut for story and structure, not color or final sound.
- What we need from you: does the story work, is the product clear, is anything missing.
- What to ignore for now: temp music, color, placeholder supers.
- When the round closes: a date and a time, with the name of the person who collects the notes.
For senior people who will not open a link, book a 20 or 30 minute live session at a fixed time instead. Watching together, with one person taking notes on the frames, often gets better input in less time than a link that sits unopened for a week. For what makes each note usable once it arrives, see how to give video feedback an editor can act on.
What do you do when someone still turns up in round three?
Thank them, log the note, and let the named decision maker choose whether it changes the plan.
Even with a good map, someone will appear late: a new hire, a regional lead who was on holiday, a chief executive who saw the film over someone’s shoulder. Do not argue the note on its merits in front of them. Instead:
- Record the note with the name, the date and the round.
- Ask the decision maker whether it overrides something already agreed.
- If it does, treat it as a change with its own time and cost, and say so before the edit starts on it.
- Add the person to the round list for anything still to come.
That last step matters most. Late arrivals are usually not the problem; staying late is. A clear definition of what counts as a revision round makes this conversation about the agreement rather than about the person.
Frequently asked questions
What if a senior stakeholder has no time for round 1?
Offer a short live session at a fixed time instead of a link they will open later. If they still cannot join, agree in writing that their input comes through the named decision maker, and that later changes count as new scope.
Should the production company talk to the brand directly?
That is up to the agency, but the notes should still arrive as one list. If the brand comments directly, the agency producer still consolidates before anything goes to the edit.
Is it rude to ask a client who else will see the film?
No. Asking it at kickoff protects the client's own schedule, and most marketing leads know exactly who tends to appear late.
How many people should be in round 1?
Everyone who can change the outcome, and nobody who only needs to stay informed. Informed people can watch with a view link and do not need to send notes.